🔗 Share this article

Similar to how daylight appears from the east and goes down toward the west, supporters of Taylor Swift will heed the call for new content. Years prior to the revenue-generating, industry-transforming international takeover of her Eras Tour, Swift had developed a particularly deep and individual bond with her followers, also within the admiring sphere of pop music. That relationship, upheld by secret references, long-running imagined relationships and perhaps her own metaverse, may be real and special and nutritive, a reliable vessel through personal challenges – I have experienced it. But years into her imperial era, Swift’s cyclical feeding of the audience is beginning to look rather than a shared commitment and increasingly manipulative, the various limited releases and exclusive records and special store editions comparable to a luxury fee on her most loyal.

The Newest Release

The latest of these is the Life of a Showgirl movie – or, more accurately, a “launch event” film for her new album The Life of a Showgirl, out this Friday. Officially billed as the Album Launch Celebration of a Showgirl, it includes of track commentaries, behind-the-scenes snippets and a single video (played twice), casually compiled into a single feature-length viewing. This is the kind of material any other artist would put on YouTube, but and Swift, having already asserted box office domination with her last concert recording, chooses to release into theaters from 3-5 October. Anticipating a $30 million debut domestically, it will almost certainly be the top-earning movie during its run – unfortunately, considering it hardly counts as a visual aid to the album, not to mention something remarkable in her extensive catalog of content.

Theater Viewing

When viewed in theaters, The Official Release Party surrounding the album at least mirrors the album it celebrates – formulaic, shallowly upbeat, featuring uninspired production and first-draft quality suggesting a creator up against a deadline. Further evidence of what critic Spencer Kornhaber described as Swift’s burnout era. In an unpolished opening filmed direct to camera, Swift, humbly awkward and self-deprecating as usual, promotes the release as “sort of a journey of the creative influences” representing a dynamic, stimulating phase”.

Aside from a behind-the-scenes featurette on the visual piece broken into 5-minute sections, the event is predominantly clips that show song words along with a segment from the related production repeatedly. This works for casual watching at a party, but a drawback as the main event for a record that is better experienced casually, its tepid soft-rock and memorably embarrassing lines allowed to wash over you superficially. Perhaps one needs to be drunk; other than a single shout for the astoundingly un-self-aware Cancelled!, it was crickets at the early family viewing.

Lyric Insights

She includes each track with a short explanation of her inspiration – generally appreciated, even critics would argue it’s uninteresting – yet they largely are generalizations, professed enthusiasm and ensuring legal safety (such as securing approval from the George Michael estate to sample the song Father Figure). She traditionally remains vague regarding tracks that plainly reference individuals, but the lack of detail now appears especially futile. Absent is any discussion of the album’s muse, the football star, though she has been unusually open about their happy relationship in promotional interviews this week. The frequently analyzed and wildly miscalculated negative comment in Actually Romantic gets described as an affectionate note to a critic. (Curiously, a biting “attention is affection and an abundance from you, exacerbates the issue.) The lusty, pun-heavy that track, starring [redacted]’s “redwood tree”, is promoted as a track regarding beliefs including a sanitized, knowing glance toward the audience.

Connection and Storytelling

She continues to excel at implying connection from her elite position in pop music; she is talkative and interesting guide, though not always truthful regarding her creations. (It isn't the energetic collection as promoted on New Heights.) That especially shines during professional moments; the standout scenes, by far, are when she cedes space to her many collaborators – one contributor, the movement designer, and the cinematographer, among others – and to the disciplined pace of a music video shoot. These behind-the-scenes glimpses – a scene from a virtual meeting, banter with performers, improving a shot – remain as compelling as they are short and tantalizing. They show simultaneously the collective and the machinery supporting her brand, the true substance behind showgirl life.

Overall Assessment

Perhaps assembling more, combining calculation with transparency, proved too difficult for her hectic agenda of lowering rewards. And perhaps loyal enthusiasts of the album – recognizing their existence – could see merit in this basic package of Target treats valuable. However, leading cinema earnings with so little is not a pop victory. It results in one more profitable item in her commercial domain.

• The artist: The Launch Film of a Showgirl is currently showing